Registers Of The Voice

The subject of vocal registers is a difficult one--difficult to

understand and, when understood, difficult to make intelligible to

others. In fact, it is so difficult that some people get rid of it by

calmly asserting that there are no registers. This is unfortunate,

because the blending of the registers, the smoothing out of the voice

where one register passes over into another, the elimination of the

"break" between hem, is one of the greatest problems which the teacher

of voice-production is obliged to solve. Like so many other branches

in the art of voice-production, the subject is complicated by initial

misunderstandings. Numerous people suppose, for example, that the vocal

registers are synonymous with the different kinds of voices, and speak

of the alto, soprano, bass or tenor register as if register stood for

quality, which it does not. Another complication results from the fact

that certain phenomenal voices, chiefly tenor, literally rise superior

to the law of vocal registers. Thus, a phenomenal tenor like Duprez sang

with ease the whole tenor range, including the high C, in the powerful,

vibrant "chest" register, whereas the average tenor, while producing

a great portion of his voice in the chest register, is obliged at a

certain point in the ascending scale to pass into the "middle" and

beyond that into the "head" register.



The breaks that occur in average voices at certain points of the scale

have established the divisions of the voice into registers. These breaks

can be accounted for on scientific grounds; and if the physiology of

voice-production had done no more than explain the why and wherefore of

vocal registers, it would have justified itself through this alone.



Suppose there were a man able to produce the entire male vocal compass,

from deepest bass to highest tenor. While for every note throughout the

entire compass there would be subtle changes in the adjustment of the

vocal tract, the following also would be true:--That, beginning with the

lowest note and throughout the first octave of his voice, the changes in

the adjustment of the vocal tract would not alter the general character

of the adjustment for that octave; that, on entering the second octave,

there would be a tendency toward change in the general adjustment of the

vocal tract; while, for the production of the remaining notes above, an

almost startling change in the adjustment of the vocal tract would take

place. The same would be true if a woman, capable of producing the

entire female vocal compass, were to begin with the lowest contralto and

sing up to the highest soprano tone. It is the general character of the

adjustment of the vocal tract for a certain range of notes in the vocal

scale that determines each register, the two principal changes in

adjustment causing two breaks in the smooth progression of the voice.



Allowing for the fact that the male voice is an octave below the female

voice, but in all other respects corresponds with it in range, the

adjustment of the vocal tract throughout each register is the same for

both men and women singers. There is, I fear, a prevalent notion on

the part of the musical public that each voice has its own separate

registers; that, for example, the registers of the soprano voice are at

different points of the scale from those of the alto, and those of the

tenor at different points from both of these. But this is not the case.

Always allowing for the octave difference between the male and female

voice, the registers for all voices are at fixed points of the scale and

are, or should be, sung by all voices with the same adjustment of the

vocal tract. A few examples will make this clear.



The lowest register for female voice is:



[Music: F3-F4]



that for male voice:



[Music: F2-F3]



i.e., an octave lower. These are the first eight notes of the alto of

the female voice and of the bass of the male voice. Alto and bass sing

these notes with precisely the same adjustment of the vocal tract. The

vocal cords in this register vibrate along their entire length, the

space between them, also the "cup" and the general adjustment of the

vocal tract, are open. A good soprano can come down into this register

as far as [Music: C4] and a good tenor as far as [Music: C3], and when

these voices come down into this register they too sing with the same

adjustment of the vocal tract as is used for the same tones by alto

and bass. This, therefore, constitutes the lowest register for all

voices--not because it consists of certain notes, but because these

notes require the same general adjustment of the vocal tract for their

production by all voices.



When it comes to the next or middle register:--[Music: F4-F5] for

female voices (and an octave below for male voices), soprano and

tenor sing through this entire register with ease, using a slightly

different adjustment of the vocal tract from that which they employed

when they went down into the lowest register. The ordinary alto stops

at C in this register, as does also the bass at an octave lower. When

they enter it their vocal tract adjusts itself to it and corresponds

with the adjustment employed in it by soprano and tenor. In this

register the vocal cords still vibrate along their entire length,

but as the voice progresses upward, they show a tendency to shorten

the glottic chink, and the cup, as well as the adjustment of the

entire vocal tract, tends to become less open. It is the register

of transition, placed between the lowest and highest, as if to bridge

over the interval.



The highest register: [Music: F5-C6] (an octave lower for male

voice) calls for an extraordinary change in the adjustment of the vocal

tract. The vocal cords are pressed tightly together at the rear and

sometimes both at the rear and front. These portions thus cease to

vibrate. Only the small free parts vibrate and these only at the edges.

As the voice progresses up the scale the stop action ceases, the

elliptical opening and the cup become smaller, and the entire vocal

tract is, comparatively speaking, contracted. This register practically

belongs only to sopranos and tenors. For example, although some

baritones are capable of adjusting their vocal tracts to this register,

their voices lose the baritone timbre, take on a feminine quality, and

become male altos.



In other words, there are three registers, and they correspond for all

voices, but certain voices sing more in one register than in the others.

Thus, the lowest register is the special province of the alto and the

bass; soprano and tenor can come down only a few notes into it. The

middle and the highest registers are the special province of soprano

and tenor. The ordinary alto and bass can come up only part way into

the middle register and cannot follow soprano and tenor at all into

the highest.



The division of the registers which I have made is subject to many

practical exceptions, which so far I have avoided mentioning, because I

wanted to fix in the reader's mind the fact that the registers are the

same for all voices and are determined by the special adjustment of the

vocal apparatus required for their production, and not by voice-quality.

Now and then in a generation there may appear upon the scene a singer,

usually tenor, who for his high notes is not obliged to adopt the

somewhat artificial adjustment required by the highest register, but can

sing all his tones in the easier adjustments of the lowest or middle

register. But he is a phenomenon, the exception that proves the rule.

Another practical exception to my rigid division of the registers is

furnished by the overlapping of registers, the capacity of a singer

to produce the lower notes of one register with the vocal adjustment

employed for the higher notes of the register below, and vice versa;

so that where the registers meet there are possibly some half a dozen

optional notes. Most basses and baritones, for example, sing only in

one register, that is, they carry the vocal adjustment for the lowest

register into the notes they are able to sing in the register above.

These exceptions will be considered later. At present, in order to

treat this difficult subject in something that at least approaches an

elementary manner, it is necessary to make the division of the vocal

scale into registers a somewhat rigid one.



It is, then, the three different adjustments of the vocal tract which

determine the three divisions of the vocal scale and likewise the

positions or registers for each division. The basis, therefore, for the

division of voice-production into registers is not haphazard, but rests

on the science of physiology. That there are not separate registers for

men and women is due to the fact that men's voices run parallel to those

of women at an interval of an octave below, and that, note for note, the

adjustment of the male vocal tract is the same as that of the female

vocal tract an octave above. For this reason basses and baritones,

although singing an octave below contraltos and altos, sing in the same

registers; for this reason also, tenors, although singing an octave

below sopranos, employ the same registers. I am, of course, speaking

of average voices, not of phenomenal ones.



Mackenzie has defined a register as a series of tones of like quality

producible by a particular adjustment of the vocal cords. Mills defines

register as a series of tones of a characteristic clang, timbre, color

or quality due to the employment of a special mechanism of the larynx in

a particular manner. Both definitions practically mean the same thing.

What I object to in them is their use of the word "quality," and

Mackenzie's limitation of the adjustment to the vocal cords and Mills'

to the larynx. The adjustment takes place throughout the entire vocal

tract. Indeed, one of the claims I make for this book is, that it does

not limit the voice-producing factor to the vibrations of the vocal

cords, but while recognizing the importance of these, also considers

the importance of the rest of the vocal tract in relation to them. Other

writers hold that voice is produced solely by the vibrations of the

vocal cords, and that the rest of the vocal tract is concerned merely

with determining the timbre of the voice. But I do not limit the

function of the vocal tract below and above the cords simply to voice

quality. To produce a given tone requires not only vibration of the

cords but an adjustment along the entire tract and especially a

change in the size and shape of the cup space. If one wished to be

exasperatingly accurate one might say that each adjustment constituted

a register, and that in every voice there were as many registers as there

are tones. But surveying the progress of the voice up the vocal scale,

and as a whole, it is found that up to a certain point the general

character of adjustment within the vocal tract is the same, that

beyond that point there is a change to another adjustment of a general

character, and further beyond still another--in other words, that there

are three registers.



Some writers recognize only two physical changes in the mechanism of the

vocal tract and consequently only two registers instead of three. They

dispense entirely with the middle register because the general change

there in the adjustment within the vocal tract is not, in their opinion,

sufficient to determine a new register. In point of fact, however, while

the lower vocal range calls the vocal cords into vibration along their

entire length, and while for the highest range only a portion of the

edges of the vocal cords vibrate, the adjustment for the medium tones

shows a gradual change from the first condition to the third. It is a

bridge by which the voice crosses in safety from the lowest to the

highest register--a register of transition, but a register withal.



Moreover, as the voice progresses upward through the scale, three

distinct physical sensations are experienced by the singer according

as to whether he is singing low, middle or high. There is one physical

sensation for the lower, another for the middle and a third for the

higher notes. This would indicate that there is, after all, more of a

change in the adjustment of the vocal tract for the middle notes than is

apparent superficially, and confirms the position of those who hold that

there are three vocal registers instead of two.



In voice-production of the lower notes there is a physical sensation of

vibration in the upper chest; on the medium notes, in the pharynx; on

the higher notes, in the head. These physical sensations have determined

the names of chest register for the lower and head register for the

higher range of tones. Strictly speaking, the middle range should be

denominated pharyngeal or throat register, but usually it is called the

medium or middle register. In the chest register the vibrations of the

vocal cords are slow and heavy; the vocal tract being in its relaxed,

open adjustment, the larynx sinks slightly and, the vibrations taking

place in their nearest proximity to the chest, they are communicated to

it. In the middle register the adjustment of the vocal tract is more

closed than in the chest register, the larynx rises a little, the shape

of the vocal tract is determined largely by the relative positions

assumed by the epiglottis and the soft palate, and the vibrations no

longer can communicate themselves to the chest, but are felt in the

pharynx. In the head register the vocal cords come together at one end,

sometimes at both ends, and only the upturned edges of the resulting

small aperture vibrate, throwing the sensation of vibration up into the

head. In every way Nature seems to indicate that there are three vocal

registers.



The most extreme limits of human voice so far known were found in the

voices of Ludwig Fischer, a bass singer, and of Lucrezia Agujari (La

Bastardella), a florid soprano. Fischer created the role of Osmin in

Mozart's "Entfuehring aus dem Serail." His voice went down to contra F

[Music: F1] an entire octave lower than the ordinary bass singer.

La Bastardella sang as high as [Music: C7] or an octave higher than what

usually is spoken of as soprano "high C." These, however, were marvellous

voices, so extraordinary that they form part of the history of singing.

Indeed, Baker, in his "Biographical Dictionary of Musicians," credits

Fischer with D--a^1 [Music: D2-A4].



A reasonable statement of the vocal compass would be 2-1/2 octaves, or

[Music: F3 to C6] for female voice and the same, an octave lower, for male

voice. Allowing for unusual voices, the statement would be as follows:



[Music:



Treble staff:

Low or Chest Register. D3-F4

Middle Register. G4-F5

High or Head Register. G5-F6



Bass staff:

Low or Chest Register. C2-F3

Middle Register. G3-F4

High or Head Register. G4-C5]



This musical example shows that save for the lowest note of the bass

voice and the three highest of the soprano, the male and female compass

parallel each other at an interval of an octave apart, and that the

division of the registers is the same for both.



Still utilizing the same musical example, but noting now the two chief

divisions of male and female voices (bass and tenor in the male and alto

and soprano in the female), the example would be divided as follows:



[Music:



Alto.

Low or Chest Register. D3-F4

Middle Register. G4-F5



Soprano.

Low or Chest Register. C4-F4

Middle Register. G4-F5

High or Head Register. G5-F6



Bass.

Low or Chest Register. C2-F3

Middle Register. G3-E4



Tenor.

Low or Chest Register. B[flat]2-F3

Middle Register. G3-F4

High or Head Register. G4-C5]



It must be borne in mind that registers overlap, that they extend up

and down one into another, and that at points where this occurs it is

optional with the singer in which of the two overlapping registers he

will produce his tones. There are many singers who can sing at will the

lower half of the middle register either in chest or middle, and the

upper half of the middle either in middle or head. It is to be noted,

however, that it is easier to bring down a tone from a higher into a

lower register than to force up a register, the latter proceeding often

being ruinous to the voice.



Duprez, a phenomenal tenor, could, as I have stated, sing the whole

tenor range in the chest register. He could emit the ut de poitrine,

which means that he could sing even tenor high C in the chest register.

The result was that half the tenors of Europe ruined their voices trying

to imitate him. For they ignored the natural three-register divisions of

the voice, and thought they could accomplish with their average voices

what is reserved only for phenomenal ones.



There are three registers; and the interrelations between these and

the different voices within the male and female range must now be

considered.